Carrier choice between EPON and GPON
NTT: EPON or GPON
Background: discussion about “EPON or GPON?” is hot and interesting in different countries or different telecom vendors.
Mr Fujimoto from NTT talked about the features and difference between EPON/GEPON and GPON application situations, and which one would be the best choice for NTT, or even Japan telecom market.
Which is the answer?
Though GPON’s higher 1.25/2.5G up/downlink bandwidth, attracting more and more telecom carriers and many ISP, also data and trends from ftth area indicate higher growth in GPON.
But EPON has better IOT(Interoperability Test) application at current stage, with rich suppliers/manufacturers resource and more mature “triple play” and “EPON+EoC” solution commercial cases.Furthermore, GEPON solution have better quotation at the same time.
Gigabit PON (GPON) standard formulated from the ITU/FSAN,and the other is Ethernet PON (EPON) standards developed by the IEEE 802.3ah working group.
IEEE 802.3ah EPON Framework
P2P Emulation and Shared Media Emulation
Logical Port Availability
An Efficient DBA Mechanism for EPON
The whole family of MPCP title related to EPON
High Performance EPON
GPON Network Parameter Description
Protection switching network requirements
PMD layer specifications
2.488Gbps downstream optical interface parameter specifications
1.244Gbps upstream optical interface parameter specifications
Physical layer overhead allocation
GPON TC layer specification
GTC multiplexing structure and protocol stack introduction
GTC frame structure introduced
ONU registration activation process
Alarms and performance
OMCI message structure described
OMCI Device Management Framework
OMCI implementation principles outlined
|Standard||ITU.T G.984.1/2/3/4||IEEE 802.3h|
|Upstream Rate(Mbit/s)|| 155/622/1 244/2 488||1250|
|Bearer Network||ATM, Ethernet, TDM||Ethernet|
|QOS||Very good，including Ethernet, TDM, ATM||Good, only ethernet|
|Optical Budget||Class A/B/C||Px10/Px20|
|Ranging||Equalization Delay(EqD)||Round Trip Delay(RTD)|
|DBA||Standard Format||Manufacturer Customize|
|TDM Support||TDM over Ethernet,(PWE3, CESoEthernet)or native TDM)||TDM over Ethernet,(PWE3, CESoEthernet)|
|OAM||ITU-T G.984 (Strong)||Ethernet OAM，SNMP Option（weak）|
Table from “Difference between GPON and EPON (ii)“–FOT FTTH Blog.